Cayman Net News
   Welcome to Cayman Net News Online: Today's print edition 
Search: web our site     



News from the Cayman Islands for
LOCAL NEWS
Prev    Next

PPM counteracts UDP charges

Published on Thursday, April 9, 2009Email To Friend    Print Version


PPM candidates listen to their leader Hon Kurt Tibbetts as he addresses the party’s official campaign launch on North Sound Road on Tuesday night. (Seated R-L) Osbourne Bodden, Moses Kirkconnell, Hon Anthony Eden, Joey Ebanks and Alfonso Wright.

Exhorting a crowd of at least 1,000 to vote for continued progress, the ruling People’s Progressive Movement (PPM) launched its campaign for the 20 May elections on Tuesday night.

The rally, headed by Leader of Government Business, Hon Kurt Tibbetts, sought primarily to counter charges by opposition candidates, including the United Democratic Party (UDP) and what Mr Tibbetts consistently referred to as the “not-so-independent” candidates, focusing primarily on fiscal management.

“No one, neither the UDP nor the not-so-independents, no one, can accuse us of corruption,” Mr Tibbetts said, leading off speeches by each of the 10 PPM hopefuls at the George Town gathering near the Compass Centre.

“We are open and transparent and people know where the money is going and how it is spent,” he said referring to ongoing accounting arrears throughout Ministries, Portfolios and government-owned companies, most of which have failed to close their annual books for at least four years, leaving unaccounted nearly $1.5 billion in expenditures.

“These accusations have never been substantiated by facts,” he said, explaining to the crowd the process of annual revenue collections, expenditures and operating expenses in a sort of government budgeting primer.

“We have forecast an operating deficit, but there has been no reduction in services to the public. There has been no new hiring, but no layoffs of civil servants,” he said.

A $13 million surplus originally projected had been offset by unpredictable expenses such as Hurricane Paloma recovery, overseas medical costs, the anti-corruption Special Police Investigation Team and a Commission of Inquiry “called by His Excellency the Governor”, Mr Tibbets said, pointing out it had been convened against the advice of the elected Government.

Revenue shortfalls had compounded the problem, creating a $13 million deficit, but Government was scheduled to record $126 million in cash holdings by the 30 June end of the fiscal year, he said.

He called local economic fundamentals “very strong”, saying “we are weathering the economic storm far better than many neighbouring countries – and some of the pictures are not very pretty”.

A series of speeches by district candidates essentially reinforced Mr Tibbetts message of reliability, experience and practiced managerial professionalism, exhorting voters: “Don’t stop the progress.”
Accompanying the addresses was a 28-page glossy brochure titled “From Promise to Performance”, outlining PPM accomplishments across a wide range of sectors from financial services to sports, environment, healthcare, public safety and road improvements.

Missing was discussion of Cayman Airways, health insurance, the cost of living, Caribbean Utilities Company or job and vocational training.

Answering UDP criticism about overspending, however, Minister for Infrastructure Hon Arden McLean rhetorically asked the opposition what projects they would not have undertaken.

“The UDP is great on talking. They talk the talk, in fact, but the PPM walks the walk. Tell me,” he said, “what are the projects we should not have done?

The Esterley Tibbetts Highway extension?

The schools they broke ground on, but never built?

The East-West Arterial Highway?

Tell the people you would not have built them,” he said.

“There is much more to be done in this country,” Mr McLean said, “and I need to work with people I can trust. If you put the UDP back in power, you will put your country back 30 years.”

 
Reads : 827

Comments:

Roy Tatum:
UDP - Still being careless with the truth. The UDP has been saying on their platform and in print that $1.83 is what the PPM and the National Assessment of Living Conditions %28NALC%29 report claims Caymanians can live on per day. Well, as usual, the UDP are stretching the truth in the hopes that you will believe them. Let’s examine what the NALC report actually states.

Indigence Line
The NALC report speaks to an Indigence Line - this refers to income received by the extreme poor in our society, who are likely homeless, do not work, and who somehow manage to survive on very little. We all know who these people are - they hang around our stores and sleep on our benches, and periodically ask us for a handout. We do not have very many, but they do exist.

With regard to this group, the report states that “The indigence line was estimated at CI$1.83 per day, which represented the lowest possible cost of consuming 2,400 kilo calories in the Cayman Islands in 2007.” Essentially, to survive, we need about 1,500 calories, with the average person supposedly consuming about 2,400 calories per day. The report concluded that it was possible to purchase some food stuff for $1.83 per day %28$668 per anum%29 that provided 2,400 calories. With this amount, one is not paying utilities, rent, school fees, insurance, etc - one can only survive or subsist at this level, and just barely.

So no, the report does not claim that Caymanians can live on $1.83 per day - clearly this is not living; and clearly the UDP understands this and are deliberately blurring the facts. But sadly, we are used to their tactics.

Poverty Line and Vulnerability Line
The report also speaks to a Poverty Line of $3,983 per anum, and a Vulnerability Line of $4,979 per anum. Obviously, these amounts are far more than the $668 per year %28$1.83 daily%29 noted for indigents – again, making a clear distinction between people who are poor or vulnerable and the very severe poverty of indigents.

One may argue as to whether the professionals who produced the report did a good job at assessing where the various ‘lines’, including the poverty line, should be - but as it was done under the auspices of the Caribbean Development Bank, one would believe that the findings would be properly vetted. Additionally, the professional firm who did the report has been doing this work since the early 1990s, and has done work for the World Bank; the UN; and various Caribbean countries and NGOs

But regardless of one’s opinion on where the numbers should be; the facts are that the NALC report does not state what the UDP claims it does; and they know it does not. And they also know that the report contains some very useful information that can, and will, be used to develop policies to assist the poor as we move the country forward.

So Cayman - do not be fooled by the UDP and their false adverts - we already know that they make a habit of being careless with the truth. This is yet another example.


Back...

Send us your comments!  

Send us your comments on this article for publication in our Readers' Forum or as a Letter to the Editor. All fields are required and in the interest of openness and transparency we will no longer accept anonymous submissions. We therefore request that all submissions include a name for publication, regardless of content. We will in special circumstances protect a writer's identity only after we have established good cause for anonymity, otherwise we will not be able to publish the submission.

For your contribution to reach us, you must (a) provide a valid e-mail address and (b) click on the validation link that will be sent to the e-mail address you provide.  If the address is not valid or you don't click on the validation link, it will be a waste of your time typing your submission because we will never see it!

Your Name:
Your Email: (Validation required)
Comments:
Enter Validation Code *